如何看待瑪麗亞凱莉在2017年NYE上的演唱事故？
歐天吧的狗 @戴克斯特 都跑到知乎上來了，趕緊回你們歐天吧去造作吧，不要在這裡丟人現眼。抓馬queen 狗die吧！接下來我來試圖還原事情真相1.牛本山早準備演小品的，結果主辦方在《友誼天長地久》對嘴完成後，想繼續讓牛本山唱歌，並毫無預料的把音樂放出來了，牛本山表示不接受，果斷丟掉耳返，拒絕演唱，繼續表演小品，並在完成表演後表述「It is what it is」以及「couldnt be better」扭頭就走，並於2017年年初開啟歐美娛樂圈第一撕「Shit happens」，然後祝福全世界人民新年快樂。2.DCP團隊隨後撕牛本山團隊不綵排，不檢查，耍大牌【之後有人民群眾指出牛本山居然綵排了兩輪】
3.隨後牛本山經紀人兼撕逼擔當stella發文撕新年晚會主辦方DCP，故意給爛的耳返，故意不換爛的耳返，並和牛本山說耳返問題是因為化妝間有屏蔽所以沒聲音並不會影響後面的表演，進而直接導致整個演唱會撲街。
4.DCP在撕逼擔當的公開撕逼中，也公開回應說他們是專業的，不可能專門的撕牛本山。5.牛本山為了明年還能繼續演小品，也公開回應相信DCP是專業的，不過以後不會再相信自己團隊以外的團隊了。意思是小品繼續演，但是以後要我演小品得我來carry全場！綜上：牛本山本來就是演小品的，lipsyn與否，playback與否都無關，牛本山根本不care，「I cant see you，I cant hear you，you dont exist to me」！根本不存在接唱、假唱，也就不存在好看與不好看。 @戴克斯特 可以回歐天吧了。下面轉CNN的描述，可看看美國官媒如何描述的。CNN: 如何避免Mariah Carey出現的狀況 （ 信息來源微信公眾號：iMariahCarey）
How to avoid a Mariah Carey meltdown
(CNN) Every day cyber bullies choose a new victim, and today they selected singer Mariah Carey. While performing live Saturday on ABCs "Dick Clarks New Years Rockin Eve with Ryan Seacrest," she had a public meltdown on stage.
Carey, a five-time Grammy winner and one of the top selling recording artists of all time, was the final act before the ball drop at midnight. Instead of witnessing the pop superstar usher in 2017 on a high note, viewers saw Carey in the middle of a technological breakdown.
Ultimately, after trying to push through several frustrating and awkward songs, she said, "It just doesnt get any better," and stormed off the stage.
And while I dont know what caused the technological issues, I do know that if you are one of the people making fun of Carey today, you likely dont do much public speaking or performing.
I am a public speaker for a living. And I know there is nothing worse than experiencing a technological breakdown in the middle of a live performance. I dont care if you are Mariah Carey or you are just presenting an idea for a new fundraiser to your local school board or church council. When you find yourself standing in front of an audience -- with a broken projector, a crashed computer, a video that wont load or a PowerPoint thats not working -- its a nightmare.
Time suddenly stops. Your heart races. You feel a mixture of vulnerability, frustration and embarrassment all at once. And your thoughts only compound the issue. Your focus immediately goes to whats wrong, and you can no longer remember your carefully rehearsed remarks.
At one point or another, each of us will experience this terrifying sensation. And while it is unavoidable, there are several ways we can reclaim focus and take control of the situation. Carey almost succeeded. She almost made it through, but she just missed the very last (and hardest) step — assuming full control by winging it.
So here are a set of steps to consider when faced with a similar predicament:
1. Take a breath
When Carey realized that the songs were not playing as they should, she paused, breathed and surveyed the extent of the damage.
And you can do that too. Remember, the audience has no idea what is supposed to happen. If you find yourself in the middle of a sales pitch or presenting a project in front of a class and you cant remember a detail, take a breath and remind yourself that only you know what is "supposed" to happen.
If you change mid-stream or if you leave something out, there is a good chance no one will notice. Most problems resolve themselves within a few seconds, so take that deep breath. It will help you stay calm and give the issue a chance to heal.
2. Tell the audience theres a problem
If you find the problem becoming a persistent issue, inform the audience. Notice, thats exactly what Mariah did. She told the audience, "We cant hear," acknowledging a technological issue she, herself, could not resolve. If she had made a joke about the situation, it would have been even better.
Talking about the problem accomplishes three goals. First, it humanizes you and puts the audience on your side because they immediately feel bad that you are dealing with this issue. Second, it calms your mind to talk about it -- rather than simply think about it. Third, if there is an audiovisual team or a larger production team (as was the case with Carey), it alerts them to the issue immediately.
3. Keep going
Next, do your best to just keep going, despite the broken clicker, buffering video or issue with the lights. Carey did that as well. She told the audience, "Well just sing." And even as she missed some of the lyrics and struggled to keep up with the pre-recorded version, she acknowledged the issue and pushed forward saying, "Were missing some of the vocals, but it is what it is." And as ABC started cutting to shots of the crowd, rather than Carey, she suggested fixes. But in the end, ABC couldnt pull it together.
Carey was alone, in the dark and disconnected from the show. Thats ABCs fault, not hers, and she deserved credit for daring to keep going.
4. Abandon Plan A and assume control by winging it
This is the one thing Carey failed to do. After several failed attempts, she walked off stage. But she could have reclaimed control. She could have stepped to the center of the stage and simply winged it. Carey could have pulled out her earpiece, told ABC to cut the technology and clear the stage, and sang the last song a cappella style.
Of course, this wouldnt have been easy to do. It requires a level of self-monitoring and control that is particularly difficult to summon in a moment of intense stress. But it is possible.
And while the performance may not have been perfect, it would have demonstrated grit, commitment and control — characteristics that would have endeared Carey to her audience, more so than any song she could sing.
So when all else fails, embrace Plan B and improvise.
***
Mel Robbins is a CNN commentator, legal analyst, best-selling author and keynote speaker. She also is a contributing editor for Success magazine. In 2014, she was named outstanding news talk-radio host by the Gracie Awards. The opinions expressed in this commentary are hers.
閱讀原文利益相關：MC粉
首先，我是不會說MC沒有假唱接唱的情況。一句話，兩者都有責任。
當時發生的視頻來看，她本身應該是情感海豚音部分接唱/最後一首逼攏全真唱，而且在表演過程中她的耳返掉了，聽不清楚音樂，根本無法唱，正常來講，其實我覺得她情感估計也打算全真唱，因為16年牛姐的嗓音恢復的不錯，逼攏更是奇怪，她要是真假唱，根本沒必要一直在台上走和互動，而且我比較欣賞她一點，她沒有主動去對嘴，而是不斷的說話，互動，這點是很明智的，而且說實話，雖然牛姐年紀大了之後雖然存在假唱接唱的情況，但是她有首歌是絕對不會接唱假唱的——VOL。（愛的幻覺）本來看完視頻，我覺得她自己也好，團隊也好，真的很不注意。
可以說我最開始70%都歸咎於牛姐這方的，但是從後期進展，我發現主辦方的言辭也有問題，讓我不得不懷疑，這事故其中有主辦方的一些意圖存在，它居然說牛姐沒有去綵排。而在綵排時候可是發了INS圖片的，怎麼說，這是個事故，雙方都有責任。
還有，其實牛姐假唱接唱只要是很熟悉的粉絲或者聲樂專家，很容易能聽出來的。（本人不是）
可是這些都是她嗓音倒嗓才頻繁發生，最初她根本每個live都用心唱，連去個酒吧表演都全真聲表演，而她早期的歌每一首都是高能耗的歌曲，唱的多，對嗓音的傷害不是一點半點。這點哪怕是現今正當紅的歌手也不一定像她這麼用心，而她唱法不怎麼科學，也不會保養嗓子。花無百日紅。
PS：我對牛姐的團隊一直都不怎麼待見，公關太差，身邊都是恭維她的人，感覺都把她當成金主，拚命的榨乾她，她現在活躍還好，不活躍，分分鐘大難臨頭各自飛。看她紀錄片感覺她和團隊的人太親近了，讓他們把自己太當回事了，缺乏約束，辦事效率不高，關鍵時候總出問題。
表示這樣的團隊對她事業完全是個障礙。
還有，至於這個事故本身會給她帶來什麼影響，就是巡演的口碑比較差，路人的好感降低而已，跟超級碗事件完全不是一個概念。比01年911相比，小巫見大巫，01年那時才是完整的牆倒眾人推。
原因如下：
超級碗——珍妮 事業正當紅，沒出現什麼低谷或者什麼，都是很平穩的過渡，粉絲基礎應該來說還是沒有完全打穩。所以這事件給她造成的打擊絕對是堪比911那時給牛姐的打擊的。也就是牆倒眾人推。
2017年事故——牛姐事業基本處於過氣養老狀態，憑著20年前的聖誕只要你保持每年的一定活躍度，地位早在00年代第一個10年奠定好了，所以即使出現這種情況，愛她的死忠和粉絲根本不會因為這事情脫粉，（05的世紀大回春圈住了好多死忠粉）。而且牛姐已經是47歲接近50的人，這根本也不會給她事業帶來什麼巨大影響，因為階段不一樣。
她最後一首冠單是在08年，相對今天也接近9年了，最後一首新單曲高位是在13年的牛美麗，才15，所以即使在現在對她來推牆，也沒有拿得出的成績來推。反正回顧90年代和00年代，兩個十年冠的人，還是MC，這是改變不了的事實。該死忠的粉絲，都已經打得好牢了。
她到現在還能活躍的原因，也就是聖誕還要你給她保持很大的熱度了。
最後，希望她能一直活躍下去，哪怕說說小品也好，vocal系已經不多了。最重要是健康長壽，和孩子過得開開心心。
我不是MC的粉，但是她唱歌真的超厲害，這次的活動事故，我站MC，畢竟沒人願意把自己的口碑毀在這麼大舞台的表演上。
至於最近幾年假唱的問題，請看視頻：http://m.weibo.cn/1793606922/4056283521312674
瀏覽過歐天吧，真不知道存在的意義是什麼，估計也就是一群初中生秀智商的在嘩眾取寵吧（逃她倒嗓，戀情變故，事業Flop，但是有些人就是值得尊敬。因為很多的歌手靠浮誇華麗的編曲和為求搏出位的歌詞來吸引受眾的時候，MC只靠一把嗓子就能出一張五星專輯。希望MC能在2017soon出一張專輯，也希望Sweet sweet fantasy能來華開演唱會，我一定會去的。小鮮肉小花們如流水，但是唱片工業的巨星卻是真真鐵打的。還有像什麼MC、惠特尼、MJ、麥當娜、布蘭妮這樣的唱片時代的巨星，就不要質疑人家的地位來秀自己智商了，和他們能常青樹一樣不衰的現在的所謂鮮肉小花可真沒有。關於牛姐假唱的各種新聞一直有，牛姐年紀大加上年輕時高負荷的唱高難度的歌曲，嗓音大不如前，狀態非常不穩定，現場也經常降調接唱，但是完全假唱的歌曲少之又少。稍微本質點的牛糞都能在現場里區分真唱接唱的片段，因為牛姐假唱的演技實在是太差了！但是關於跨年事故，官方有解釋，而且現場視頻也有證據，當然不能說完全可信，但是歐美天后loser就不要出來亂咬人了。第一首歌首先難度不是特別大，即使現在的牛姐也能hold住，但是後面的拖長音，作為牛糞，覺得還是有可能接唱了的。第二首之前耳返就出了問題，伴舞用大羽毛扇子遮住MC的時候一直在搞牛姐的耳返，視頻里都有，沒有耳返牛姐就開啟了喜劇模式，開始跟大家互動，視頻中有內容，都是一些關於現場出問題了之類的內容跟觀眾解釋。
這時候有一個特別讓人尷尬的地方就是海豚音接唱了，沒得說，確實尷尬。
但是有些黑子說的放錯音樂假唱失敗真的是為了黑而黑，emotions難度之高大家都知道，牛姐嗓子大不如前大家也都知道，近幾年的emotiins牛姐都是降調，躲高音加上各種即興，看過牛姐這幾年現場都知道，可以說是非常車禍了，大家也都接受了這個設定。。。。這時候如果牛姐假唱這首歌，不知道是觀眾傻還是牛姐傻。第三首we belong together 牛姐在現場視頻里已經說是cd版本了，讓大家一起唱了，此時牛姐的臉色已經非常難看了，內心估計也十分崩潰，可是還是要保持微笑:），跟著走過場對口型加上幾個安排好的喜感舞蹈動作。最後乾脆不對口型了，一甩麥克風，視頻中也能明顯看出來不耐煩翻白眼深呼吸這種動作。第三首假唱失敗更是無中生有，牛姐又不是智障，從曾經的接唱現場來說，牛姐不絕對不會用cd版本接唱。。。故意不看現場視頻或者看不懂自己主觀臆測的，只能說要不就是智障要不就是聽不懂裡面的英語。。。其實這種事故出現的頻率也不小。她自己把責任推到主辦方，我覺得勉強吧。但是就算是Janet jackson把責任推到超級碗，美國人也不會原諒她。畢竟，大場合，該做好準備的還是要做好準備是吧。這個耳返有問題，難道mariah大姐之前都不綵排不sound check嗎？當然就更不用說後面wbt的假唱了。。。
最後還是我的那個比喻：假唱就和作弊一樣，要不你就有本事一直作弊不被抓，被抓了，就認栽，別扯什麼其他人都作弊這些話。第一，也有不作弊的人啊，你這樣對不作弊的人公平？第二，為啥其他人都沒被抓就你被抓了。。第三，不僅被抓了，死相還這麼難看推薦閱讀：
※怎麼看待原諒熊大的傷者？
※車禍會導致失明是什麼原因？
※如何看待傳祺gs4事故中被撞成數截？
TAG:音樂 | 唱歌 | 車禍 | 瑪麗亞·凱莉MariahCarey |