如何看待川普被批在波多黎各遭受颶風侵襲後的災後救援不力？

01-21

我一直不知道早就關注了的這個問題怎麼回答，沒想到今天題目內容就用上了。

https://www.zhihu.com/question/65958236

這是九月二十三日POLITICO報道的救災的新聞：

http://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/23/puerto-rico-aid-hurricane-flooding-243061

Large amounts of federal aid began moving into Puerto Rico on Saturday, welcomed by local officials who praised the Trump administration"s response but called for the emergency loosening of rules long blamed for condemning the U.S. territory to second-class status.
Rossello and other officials praised the federal government for planning its response in detail before the storm hit, a contrast with what Puerto Rico has long seen as the neglect of 3.4 million Americans living in a territory without a vote in Congress or the electoral college. "This is the first time we get this type of federal coordination," said Resident Commission Jenniffer Gonzalez, Puerto Rico"s non-voting representative in Washington.

當地長官的評價是非常正面的，駐國會的無投票權代表表示「這是我們第一次得到這樣檔次的聯邦協調。」

這是FEMA9月25號的的救災明細：

Federal Government Continues Hurricane Maria Response and Relief Operations
裡面有啥自己看。

這是軍隊的救災力量集結的新聞：

Military conducting multiple operations to help Hurricane Maria-struck Puerto Rico, Virgin Islands

最重要的在這：

這是PBS的直播新聞：

Devastated Puerto Rico needs unprecedented aid, says governor

全文有興趣的自己看吧。

之前主持人一直在貼金說民主黨議員在救援波多黎各的時候的努力，什麼盡最大努力救援災區。

努力了什麼？

Jones Act - Wikipedia

每次救災都會通過國會慣常通過暫時放寬的法律。

這個作為兩院少數黨的民主黨雖然沒有辦法否決。

但是可以通過Fillbuster強行阻撓議事啊。

但民主黨顯然沒有這樣做。

多厲害，都是民主黨的功勞哦。

看看主持人的屁股。

但是最關鍵的是下面連線波多黎各總督的對話：

For more on the situation in Puerto Rico, I spoke with the territory』s governor, Ricardo Rossello.
Governor Rossello, thanks for joining us.
Let me first by asking you, what』s the latest on the Guajataca Dam? Is that still in that danger, or has that stabilized?
GOV. RICARDO ROSSELLO, Puerto Rico: Well, right now, we were unclear.
We sent a group of engineers to assess the situation. We』re going to get information in the next two hours. However, we』re still on emergency protocol, making sure people are out of harm』s way. We are assessing mitigation plans to make sure that we can stop the damage that has already occurred within the dam.
So things are still in flux. But, of course, we would rather err on the side of caution.
JOHN YANG: Governor, you say you have sent teams out to the dam. How hard is it to get information, to reach various parts of the island?
GOV. RICARDO ROSSELLO: It』s very difficult in terms of telecom. We only have 27 percent of telecom network working right now, and it』s mostly in the metropolitan area.
However, we have established certain teams that are going to the different municipalities. We have made sure that the mayors or their representatives come over here to our center of operations, so that we can communicate what the needs are and we can start being effective.
We send a crew of runners every day to every municipality, so we can get information back and forth. So it』s a little bit rudimentary, but it』s working for us at this moment, and hopefully we will have a mitigation strategy within the next 24 to 48 hours.

JOHN YANG: Governor, are you getting all the aid you need or getting it fast enough from the states?
（拿到「全部需要的援助」了嗎？拿的快嗎？這不是帶節奏么？這麼大的災怎麼可能物資一次全部到位。何況波多黎各年久失修的能源系統和港口遭到風災已經不能使用了，第一批軍隊就是去維修碼頭好讓海軍送物資的，但是看總督回復。）
GOV. RICARDO ROSSELLO: First of all, we are very grateful for the administration. They have responded quickly.
The president has been very attentive to the situation, personally calling me several times. FEMA and the FEMA director have been here in Puerto Rico twice. As a matter of fact, they were here with us today, making sure that all the resources in FEMA were working in conjunction with the central government.
We have been working together. We have been getting results. The magnitude of this catastrophe is enormous. This is going to take a lot of help, a lot of collaboration. So, my call is to congressmen and congresswomen to take action quickly and conclusively with an aid package for Puerto Rico.
We are in the midst of potentially having a humanitarian crisis here in Puerto Rico which would translate to a humanitarian crisis in the United States. So, I call upon Congress to take action immediately. You know, Puerto Ricans are proud U.S. citizens.
We have shown as much when Irma went through our region. It impacted us, but that didn』t stop us from going to the aid of other almost 4,000 U.S. citizens that were stranded in some of the islands. We gave them food, shelter. We make them out of harm』s way and we have them go back to their homes.
Now it is time for, you know, the U.S. citizens in the mainland to help Puerto Rico as well. And because we are a territory, we need to be equal, because we』re U.S. citizens, as would happen in any other state. The aftermath of this could be health emergencies, severe problems with infrastructure, and, of course, massive exodus of people of Puerto Rico, which would cause a tremendous demographic shift in Puerto Rico and in the United States.
JOHN YANG: You say it has to be consistent with the aid that went to Harvey and Irma.
Do you worry that, because that was Texas and Florida, that Puerto Rico might be overlooked or in some sense sort of forgotten in the wake of all of that?

（不甘心，接著帶節奏：「會不會因為德州和佛州也遭災了所以波多黎各受到忽視？」）
GOV. RICARDO ROSSELLO: We can』t be treated differently. You can』t build half a house.
You need to have all of the resources to restructure and rebuild Puerto Rico properly. And let me just say this. Puerto Rico』s situation is very unique. FEMA, you know, recognizes as much. So, it』s a situation where we essentially had two Category 5, 4 or 5, hurricanes go through Puerto Rico in a matter of two weeks.
This is unprecedented. And, as such, the response should be unprecedented as well.
JOHN YANG: Governor Ricardo Rossello of the U.S. territory of Puerto Rico, thank you very much for your time. And we wish you the best.
GOV. RICARDO ROSSELLO: Thank you for your thoughts and prayers. And we will be fighting to build a much better Puerto Rico.

這是當地人的態度。

BTW，這位總督可是民主黨，連續兩屆為民主黨總統候選人站台了。

Ricardo Rosselló

媒體的屁股也可見一斑了。

============================

因為波多黎各人沒有選票，所以民主黨執政的波多黎各的電力、碼頭等基礎建設並不被民主黨的執政府關心，這個颶風二連一下就把島上老舊的公共設施摧垮了，民主黨不以為恥反而高聲嚷嚷波多黎各還沒有恢複電力。

臉呢？

基建是誰搞的？

而一旦是共和黨執政，這些民主黨的左媒巴不得波多黎各多死些人好給自己攻擊共和黨總統增加籌碼。還沒怎麼呢，就已經在說這是特朗普的「卡特琳娜」了。

是是是，去年路易斯安那州，還是照常打球度假的奧巴馬和在家睡覺的希拉里比私人飛機攜帶救災物資去災區的特朗普偉光正。

四天以後，奧黑回到白宮，第一件事就是抨擊特朗普去災區作秀，然後又幾天後親自去BLM代表家中視察慰問。

然後這就不是「奧巴馬的卡特琳娜」了？

左媒的臉呢？

雙標這麼明顯？

而這次的事實是風災剛過FEMA已經在著手現場勘查了。碼頭也在修復，救災計劃在災害發生前就已經著手制定了，倒是左媒天天嚷嚷救災不力救災不力，人道主義危機人道主義危機，似乎生怕波多黎各人死的少了害的自己沒辦法攻擊共和黨的總統了。

真這麼關心受災的波多黎各人民去參加志願者啊，不用去現場。去後方準備物資，能生產生產，不能生產的就參加打包，去參加紅十字會，去給救災機構捐點小錢，去協助物資物流啊。

還沒怎麼的蹲在家裡不干事的就開始操起鍵盤噴總統了救災不力了，什麼毛病？

哦對了，這些左棍聽說特朗普削減FEMA預算的時候怎麼說的來著？

我似乎忘了，有人提醒我下么？

怕是 @丿I 丨這樣的左棍水軍又迫不及待想吃人血饅頭了。

什麼？沒有人血饅頭？

沒有人血饅頭，製造人血饅頭也要吃。

實在不行，虛構的人血饅頭也可以湊合。

這不就是左棍本色么？

推薦閱讀：

https://www.zhihu.com/question/66044907/answer/237961954

https://www.zhihu.com/question/66075843/answer/237956774

===============

@丿I 丨，你川哥今天要早點休息，今天的英語自己翻譯。

天天跟著左媒造謠然後連個內容都看不明白。

每天光是看你的翻譯都夠打你臉一次。

我都替DNC尷尬。

說明奧巴馬、希拉里一定通俄

還川普的卡特里娜。

我記得夏天哪個州眾議院補選的時候，白左先說是對川普的「全民公決」。結果派出來的人捐款90%以上來自東西海岸。然後花了十數倍的錢輸了之後又說moral victory.創造詞的能力真是穩。

呃，怎麼感覺現在的白左鬧得像是明末的東林清流一樣，為了黨爭不管不顧的，啥正事都不幹就搞黨爭。

我來知乎的第一個回答是這個：

劉翔熙：如何看川普慰問受災群眾，好評一片？

這裡再複製黏貼一下，看看媒體對不同總統的雙標多嚴重：

小布希：

Hurricane Katrina 的時候，路易斯安娜的新奧爾良大水災，總時任統小布希乘直升飛機空中巡視。當時在全美國媒體中掀起「打倒布希」的軒然大波。這種新聞在今天也可以查到,即使過了10年（事件發生在2005年，）仍然有人在罵不絕口
例如US News在2015年還在有人寫文章
Hurricane Katrina Was the Beginning of the End for George W. Bush
因為當時的媒體告訴美國民眾：美國人民不應該接受那樣一個不關心民眾疾苦的「總統先生」。

奧巴馬：

2016年，路易斯安那再次遭受的大水災的受災面積遠超當年新奧爾良。（好處水災這次靠北，處於人口密度低區域，所以直接受災人口比那次新奧爾良少不少，直接毀滅性受災人口才4萬戶，新奧爾良大概80萬左右）
而當時的現任總統奧巴馬在做什麼？
他連坐飛機視察都免了。。。按原計劃打完兩個星期的高爾夫才回家。
而民主黨總統候選人希拉里呢？在休息。。。
（在班加西淪陷前，這兩位大人物也同樣是在----休息。。。）
川普，那個被所有媒體認定的的大壞蛋！在深入黑人打砸搶燒的密爾沃基市後，就馬不停蹄地趕往路易斯安那。
而度假回來在家裡休息的總統奧巴馬知道此事，立刻在網上發了長文批判Trump，說他到災區去是去拍照的、是去擾亂社會治安的！根本不是真心關心災民。。。
當然，奧巴馬還特意地選擇性忽視了川普是帶著救災物資去的。。。

川普：

人太懶，大家直接看Joshua 和 SUTOP的回答好了

德州颶風的：知乎用戶：如何評價川普在德克薩斯遭到颶風襲擊後趕往受災一線指導搶險救援工作，並帶去聯邦對受災群眾的親切問候？

波多黎各的：

知乎用戶：如何看待川普被批在波多黎各遭受颶風侵襲後的災後救援不力？

我就能說，媒體啥時候能明白，大家都是有眼睛的么。。。

放心好了，無論Trump做什麼，怎麼做，都會有人蹦躂出來批鬥他的。還記得前幾天，Texas風災後，總統兩口子去災區視察，然後白左就開噴他們的著裝么？

睡前查了一下新聞，結果很有意思。

Carmen Yulín Cruz，波多黎各San Juan市長，在堆積如山的聯邦救災物資面前接受CNN的採訪，職責聯邦救災不力。

但是同時，波多黎各州的民主黨總督，周日再次表示救災進展順利，FEMA幹得不錯

http://www.businessinsider.com/r-puerto-rico-governor-says-relief-arriving-to-storm-ravaged-rural-areas-2017-10

San Juan隔壁的Guaynabo市市長Angel Perez在周六的採訪中表示，FEMA乾的不錯。反而是Carmen Yulín Cruz從來不肯參加FEMA舉辦的各類救災協調會議。FEMA的頭也在CNN的採訪中表達了相同的觀點，救災需要當地政府積极參与協調。

EXCLUSIVE: Fellow Puerto Rico Mayor Rips San Juan Mayor — ‘She’s Not Participating In Any Meetings’

FEMA Chief Defends Trump Tweets, Dings San Juan Mayor [VIDEO]

所以現在San Juan實際是啥情況呢？以下是MSNBC在San Juan港口現場的報告。記者身後就是堆積如山而且裝箱完畢的聯邦救災物資。但是沒有卡車頭過來運送這些物資。

09/26/2017:

San Juan港口重開，但運輸恢復緩慢。

https://www.wsj.com/articles/puerto-rico-port-reopens-but-relief-distribution-remains-slow-1506446137

09/27/2017:

美軍出動空軍，海軍，陸戰隊以及陸軍工程兵直接進入波多黎各救災。（此時波多黎各州長並未向國防部請求援助）。

US military sends ships, aircraft to Puerto Rico

Hospital Ship Heads to Puerto Rico as Military Struggles to Direct Aid

Trump administration rushes military assets to Puerto Rico amid growing crisis

09/28/2017：

國會暫時性豁免現有Jones Act，Trump簽署生效，允許非美國船隻停靠San Juan運送救援物資，以補充運力。

White House: Trump to allow foreign ships to supply Puerto Rico

同時，隨著救援物資的加速到位，島內運輸成為大問題。只有20%的卡車司機回來上班。

Puerto Rico aid supplies trapped at San Juan port: report

US MILITARY ON PUERTO RICO: "THE PROBLEM IS DISTRIBUTION"

Puerto Rico governor asking truck drivers to help transport food

同日，國防部任命三星中將傑夫里·布坎南負責指揮美軍在波多黎各救災活動。

US military"s Puerto Rico recovery to be led by decorated Army general

09/29/2017:

各路人馬開始召集卡車司機去波多黎各救援。

Trump on hurricane-damaged Puerto Rico: "We"ve never seen a situation like this"

Teamsters Recruiting Volunteer Members to Assist Puerto Rico with Tranporting Vital Supplies

09/30/2017：

負責指揮協調救災的三星中將向國防部要求更多資源，陸軍工程兵直接進入波多黎各搶修各類基礎設施。

"Not enough" troops, equipment in Puerto Rico, says general in charge of relief

DoD Accelerates Hurricane Relief, Response Efforts in Puerto Rico

下周二Trump會抵達波多黎各，拭目以待看看島內救災物資的運輸問題是否能夠得到緩解。但以美國近十年來的組織能力和救災效率來說，最近一系列颶風后的救災行動基本無可指摘。

聖胡安市長（民主黨）站在聯邦政府發送的瓶裝水前說沒有得到聯邦政府的幫助。她難道指望聯邦政府把水分到每一個人的手中？她自己手下市政府的人員呢？

在這件事情上，我川深得我黨教誨，能親臨現場關心民眾疾苦。

只是還沒學會哽咽。

白左這幫二逼，就跟被喪屍咬了一樣，完全喪失人類正常思維，站在道德制高點死活不肯下來，生怕別人搶走了。

――

奇怪了，好久沒見白左了，自從我川登基後就好像消失了……

好想再看看她們站在道德制高點上瘋子灑爽的樣子……

（我為什麼用「她們」？）

說起救災，就不得不說說Irma災害中川普個人名義捐的一百萬美元。

同樣是川普的一百萬美元，白左Liberal們在不同的情況下反應截然不同：

首先是川普在競選總統之前談自己創業經歷的時候，他這樣說道：「我爸爸當年給了我一百萬美元當做創業的啟動資金」

Liberal們的反應是這樣的：「一百萬還叫少？」

「咱們一輩子都掙不到一百萬，川普的啟動資金就有這麼多，川普真是一個何不食肉糜的萬惡土財主！！！！！！！！」

這個時候，在白左眼裡，一百萬美元是多的。

然而這次洪水之後，川普以個人名義捐贈了一百萬美元，同樣是川普，同樣是一百萬美元，Liberal們的反應卻完全不一樣了：「才一百萬美元？川普這土財主的財產足足有70億美元，才捐一百萬？」

「一百萬對川普來說算什麼？作秀！作秀！」

然而在這個時候，在白左眼裡，一百萬美元卻是少的。

所以在左派眼裡，川普的一百萬美元究竟是多還是少啊？

這雙標玩的6啊。

我記得是歷屆美國政壇一致不同意波多黎各公投加入美聯邦州的？

美國眼下這矛盾不是很顯而易見麼，公民的代表意志違反公民們的意志，公民們應該群起反對並改革美國的代表制度才是，而非整天抓著這個核心周邊的議題吵鬧，要搞清楚主要矛盾啊。

非要我再唱一次白左在哪裡就好了？

一個市長有沒有儘力救災，不是trump這種十萬八千里之外的推特網紅說了算的，是當地災民說了算！

波多黎各最大的問題是作為美國的附屬地，當地人民法律上算美國公民，但是沒有投票權，實打實的二等公民。要是波多黎各有自己的參議員眾議員和一票選民，選總統的時候能投上票說上話，trump 絕對不會是這種踩上一腳的態度。