MIUI真的抄了xposed嗎？實際是什麼情況。

01-14

小米系統涉剽竊國外XPOSED設計
這個新聞說抄了xposed的設計，本也不奇怪，國人一向在抄。只是以前一直沒有關注過xposed，知道的朋友講講？謝謝。

別邀請我不懂看新聞報道自己去理解就行了。

不請自來

說說我所知道的

首先是 rovo89 （Xposed 模塊作者）發現這個問題後在 MIUI 英文論壇上質問官方：Where does MIUI give credit for their Xposed fork?

3-11 官方管理員說：

Hi, first I would like to apologize. Sorry for causing all the bad feelings.
The devs will delete the related code soon. It was used for debugging purpose, and was not supposed to be released for public.
Again, sorry for all the inconvenience.

翻譯成中文就是我們會儘快刪除

所以，抄襲的事實是有的

接下來，rovo89 在 4-29 回復：

Any official statement on this? What about the promises that Dexspy will be removed?
I found the source code for the binary today: https://github.com/MiCode/dexspy

For some reason, any references to Xposed, me and Tunstwenty were removed, which is clearly a license violation. And I didn"t see any added code. I have filed an issue, let"s see if there will be any response... https://github.com/MiCode/dexspy/issues/1

翻譯成中文是這個 Dexspy （其實就是 Xposed）被上傳到 Github 了，並且作者信息和對 Xposed 的引用被移除。

最後他在 XDA （Xposed FAQ / Known issues）說：

MIUI/Dexspy
Symptom:

You experience bootloops after installing Xposed on MIUI. There are references to "Dexspy" in /system/bin/app_process and /system/framework/*.
Background:
MIUI forked Xposed to build something for their ROMs. When I confronted them with the evidence and asked if they at least give proper credit (as required by the license), they apologized and said it was debugging code that wasn"t meant to be in public releases. They said it would be removed "soon".
One and a half months later, people report that Dexspy is still present. There was a GitHub repository where they had published the source code. I checked it and didn"t find any additional code/features, they just removed some resource-related code. And they renamed everything, so there wasn"t a single mention of "Xposed" anymore. The "NOTICES" file in the original project mentions Tungstwenty and me as authors. They removed these lines.
So it"s not about forgetting to give credit, they intentionally obfuscated whose work they built upon (you can"t even say that, as they didn"t add any value themselves).
Solution:
Stop using MIUI. Their practices are poison for the open-source community and respectless towards a developer who has spent countless hours developing and supporting free software.
Also, don"t expect me to add workarounds for this. I know that WSM Tools (another Xposed fork) does this, but I"m tired of wasting my time for this crap.

自己翻譯……我懶得翻譯……

最後的最後就是現在：AndroidBeat 把這事抖了出來，小米被迫 blabla……

總結：小米確實有抄襲，至於是否自願改正，那就不清楚了

另外，國內對這個事件的報導也不實。Xposed 根本不是個系統，只是一個模塊

匿了

確實抄了一些