為什麼哈利波特沒跟赫敏在一起?
I am Hermione Granger, the smartest, most bad-ass sorcerer of my generation, by a mile.
Professor Snape wanted to humiliate Harry on the first day of school with some difficult questions, and guess who knew all the answers without a single day of class? I am directly responsible for at least a quarter of Gryffindor"s points earned each year, and also behind at least half of the points earned by Harry Ron. I got more Outstanding"s on my OWLs than any other student had passed.
I alone figured out that Fluffy was guarding the sorcerer"s stone, that Slytherin"s monster was a basilisk, that Professor Lupin was a werewolf, coached Harry through the Tri-wizard tournament, found out about Rita Skeeter"s secret, founded the Society for Promoting Elfish Welfare, founded Dumbledore"s Army, figured out the Ministry"s problems, voiced Harry"s story through the Quibbler, realized that the Sirius dream was a trap, trapped Umbridge in the Forbidden Forest, realized that the Half-blood Prince"s old potions book was dangerous, came up with at least 3/4 of the plans during the Horcrux hunt, and kept two idiots alive.
Harry Potter would be dead without me. And he wouldn"t have had all the stories to tell his grandchildren. Actually, he and Ron would have failed to turn in half of their homework without me. And he thinks he"s the hero? Puh-leeze. Professor Dumbledore was pulling the strings. Professor Snape was pulling the strings. I was pulling the strings. He won this game of chess because the mastermind of the game bought him the opportunity to checkmate the king with his own sacrifice. Without us, he"s nothing more than a boy with a scar.
Let me say this again, I am the smartest, most bad-ass sorcerer of my generation. How dare you judge me by who I marry? I"m Hermione fxxxing Granger. I"m not your average girl who just wants to marry a famous dude. And why is everybody so obsessed with Harry Potter, a boy who stood on my shoulders anyway? I"m going to find someone with a better sense of humor and appreciates me more. And look, I found someone who"s not only funny and appreciative and brave and loyal, but also understands the stressful life of being friends with an introvert orphan who"s weirdly bonded with Lord Voldemort.
Why can"t people just be happy for me?有點陳家洛不敢娶霍青銅的意思.
性別不一樣怎麼談戀愛
作者習慣性喂x,就像八神太一被友情男搶走了妹子一樣……
http://tieba.baidu.com/p/5388066150?share=9105fr=shareunique=5371755A26C0FBD8D7A162FE35476ACFst=1511500934client_type=1client_version=8.9.0sfc=copy
把我在貼吧寫的答案再貼過來:我支持羅赫,不支持哈赫的,我也相信羅恩會成熟起來,當然哈赫也不見得有多成熟,哈利也經常脾氣暴躁過,只是因為他對赫敏沒有愛情,所以可以理智一點。
哈赫不在一起的理由有:1.削弱哈利的個人魅力首先哈利波特不是愛情故事,哈利這個人也不是特別注重愛情,雖然我不滿羅琳把金妮給寫砸了,但是對於整個系列而言,這真的只是一個微不足道的瑕疵。羅琳確實不太擅長寫圓滿愛情,對於她不擅長的部分,她能做到掐頭去尾就不錯了,倘若讓哈利和赫敏在一起的話,勢必會把整部系列給寫砸。當然考慮到羅琳的文筆功力,哈利和赫敏在一起也會削弱哈利的個人魅力,因為整個系列都是以哈利的視角去看的,而赫敏就在他旁邊,哈利愛上赫敏,整個章節就赫敏長赫敏短的,不僅僅會降低整部小說的格調,而且還會把哈利寫成戀愛腦。2.降低羅恩的重要性看電影或許覺得降低羅恩拔高赫敏沒什麼,但是看原著就知道羅恩的個人成長和性格是非常出彩的,可以說對於哈利而言,羅恩比赫敏重要。羅琳的初衷是哈利羅恩赫敏是不可拆的鐵三角,他們任何一個都不可或缺,就像斯內普說的他們是夢之隊。所以對於這樣一個夢之隊而言,羅恩也不僅僅是作為一個捧哏角色存在的,而哈利本來就有救世主這個光環,把赫敏配給哈利明顯會削弱羅恩的重要性,鐵三角也就變成了兩個人,而沒有羅恩的哈利波特會變的非常晦暗。
3.太過嚴肅電影里哈利和赫敏可以談笑風聲開玩笑什麼的,但是這畢竟不是羅琳筆下的人物,電影里的人物已經失真了。在書裡面哈利和赫敏分享了太多傷心的情緒,包括哈7後面羅恩出走後他們幾乎沒說話,所以如果哈利和赫敏在一起,整個基調就變得很陰暗,而本來哈利波特這個小說就屬於比較暗黑的,再加上哈赫在一起的話,就真的太過嚴肅了。----------------------------------
以上都是根據羅琳的角度考慮的,不可否認的是作者確實有很大程度決定cp的走向。
但是從人物設定來看,哈赫仍然非常違和,接下來我重點要說的就是第3條。哈秋在一起的時候,秋特別敏感,經常哭啊發脾氣,赫敏很耐心地向哈利解釋。這能證明赫敏沒有秋張敏感嗎?並沒有,只能說赫敏很理智,因為她對哈利不是愛情。大家難道忘了赫敏被羅恩惹哭多少次了嗎?
羅恩一次又一次的懷疑哈利,而赫敏卻一直堅定地支持哈利。羅恩的性格比較衝動,赫敏比較理智而已,事實上她對哈利也不是完全的信任。第7部羅恩叫她選邊站的時候,難道她要跟羅恩一起拋下哈利才算真的愛羅恩?即使她跟羅恩一樣有抱怨但還是留下了,說明她是理智的,她也希望羅恩跟她一起留下,這是重點。
所有的這一切完全是因為赫敏對哈利的愛,是一種完全理智的接近於親情的愛,而不是愛情。
所以說我覺得哈赫很有違和感,赫敏對哈利很有耐心,哈利對赫敏也有依賴,就像姐弟一樣。
這種感情呢不是沒有可能產生愛情,但我真心覺得哈赫要在一起,很不合適。
哈赫迷說他倆是出生入死,為對方關心的最好搭檔。救世主跟美女學霸,簡直良配。然而哈利是一個披著救世主光環的孤兒,要說羅恩自我,哈利比羅恩更自我,那麼多東西壓在他的身上,再加上他的性格確實比較內斂一點。哈利這個人哪真的不適合結婚。
赫敏也並不是開朗活潑,或者特別堅強的人,其實她也很自卑,也很敏感,只不過她選擇了向羅恩釋放她的真實情緒。面對哈利,她只能壓抑自己的情感。
我說哈赫在一起太嚴肅就是這個原因,人物設定的問題。哈利不是一個典型的英雄人物,赫敏也不是一個自信爆棚的學霸。
羅琳筆下的人物是英式風格的,不是美式風格。倘若哈利是美國英雄的話,我估計他倆就成了,可惜那就不是我們喜歡的哈利了。
電影后期都偏向美式風格了,所以哈赫變得更多了.......作為顏值控,確實金妮跟哈利更配。(忽略電影,尊重原著)
因為赫敏和哈利性格太相似,都很強勢,難免會衝突不斷。還有就是,羅琳要把赫敏和羅恩安排在一起啊
其實網上有過長篇的論文,但是我個人感覺,主要是覺得羅恩配不上赫敏是很關鍵的一點,不是羅恩不好,只是比起哈利,確實差很多
推薦閱讀:
※哈利?波特為什麼不出像馴龍高手那樣的 3D 動畫?
※哈利波特第八個故事《被詛咒的孩子》為什麼選擇舞台劇的形式?
※一個哈利波特的主題密室 你希望如何設計?
※哈利波特中哪些人物能體現反叛精神?
TAG:哈利·波特 |