如何評價加拿大政府向謀殺美士兵的Omar Khadr道歉並支付高達一千萬加幣的賠償?

01-09

In 2010, the Supreme Court found the treatment of Khadr offended "the most basic Canadian standards".
A government source has confirmed to CBC News that Ottawa will
apologize and pay millions of dollars in compensation to former
Guantanamo Bay prisoner Omar Khadr.
Khadr — who confessed to killing a U.S. army medic
when he was 15, under interrogation that was later deemed "oppressive" —
will receive a settlement of $10.5 million, the source, speaking on
condition of anonymity, confirmed to CBC late Tuesday.
Details of the deal were first reported earlier Tuesday by unnamed
sources who spoke to The Associated Press, the Toronto Star and the
Globe and Mail.
Khadr, who now lives in an apartment in Edmonton, had been seeking $20 million in a wrongful imprisonment civil suit against Ottawa.

The government and Khadr"s lawyers negotiated the deal last month, according to The Associated Press.
Speaking to reporters in Ireland, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau would not confirm any details.
"There is a judicial process underway that has been underway for a
number of years now, and we are anticipating, like I think a number of
people are, that that judicial process is coming to its conclusion,"
Trudeau said.

等下，平時是哪些人對美國在關塔那摩侵犯囚犯人權的憤憤不平的？

1.如果美國不該在關塔那摩侵犯人權，加拿大政府對自身公民負責（無論是不是恐怖分子），做出合理賠償是應該的（參見高贊答案）

2.如果美國在關塔那摩沒有侵犯人權或者你們認為恐怖分子沒有人權（也就是不存在是否侵犯人權），那麼平時你們罵的什麼？

當然恐怖分子最好的歸宿是被1000磅JDAM直接命中

咳咳，說句政治不正確的話。事情的後繼影響極有可能和一些追求正義公平人士的設想不一樣，軍事力量以後肯定是能打死就打死，抓到活的審訊完了就一槍崩掉隨便埋了。讓你死無對證，就算髮現了也可以說是誤殺，反正賠償責任要輕不少。

這就是合法但不合理的結果，和某國交通法規一樣…

加拿大政府向卡德爾賠償是因為他的人權受到了侵害。其中包括：沒有保障他得到公平的審判，特別是在關塔納摩基地，加拿大情報人員還參與了對他的審訊，沒有告知他的權利；此外還有上屆政府拒不執行法院判決，儘早把他接回加拿大，再有就是在他回到加拿大時讓他繼續在聯邦監獄裡服刑，而不是在警備較松的省監獄。這一系列事實都經過了法庭審判，加拿大政府早已輸掉了包括讓他假釋出獄在內的一系列官司。

另外，賠償金額與其他幾位受到類似虐待的加拿大人相近。可以說是前政府設定的標杆。

在這一系列的賠償中，加拿大政府再三聲明賠償與他們和美國政府之間的糾葛毫無關係，只與人權有關。

至於謀殺美士兵一事，當然有爭議。卡德爾10歲被其父帶到阿富汗，15歲遇上這場交戰。美軍先用五百磅炸彈轟平了房屋，再是特種部隊沖入，將還活著的兩人一人擊斃，活捉另一名重傷的，就是卡德爾。戰死的美軍士兵雖說是衛生兵，但作戰時他穿的是當地人的服裝。在這種情況下，要說卡德爾犯下了謀殺罪，實在是美國政府的發明。事實上，之前在作戰中殺死對方作戰人員不是犯下戰爭罪，直到美國政府引入了新法，而且迄今為止也只有卡德爾一人被定罪。這裡還不說他是否是屬於兒童士兵的問題，以及他的認罪是否是酷刑的結果，或者說是與美國政府達成司法交易的一部分。

更新：有興趣的可以閱讀這篇：剝奪睡眠是否是酷刑？

Yes, sleep deprivation is torture

更新2：對真相感興趣的可以看這篇報道：

Omar Khadr fact check paints a clearer picture of the case and the incident underlying it | Toronto Star

According to The New York Times, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau』s government has apologized to a hardened, unrepentant terrorist who killed an American soldier, and has paid that terrorist a reported 10.5 million Canadian dollars (about $8.1 million). The Times reports:

The government of Canada on Friday formally apologized to Omar Khadr, the only Canadian imprisoned at the United States military base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. It also said that it had paid compensation to Mr. Khadr, a former child soldier, for violating his rights under Canadian law.

「On behalf of the government of Canada, we wish to apologize to Mr. Khadr for any role Canadian officials played in relation to his ordeal abroad and any resulting harm,」 the government said in its apology. 「We hope that this expression, and the negotiated settlement, will assist him in his efforts to begin a new and hopeful chapter in his life.」

His 「ordeal abroad」? Omar Khadr is an admitted terrorist, whose father was one of Osama bin Laden』s closest advisors, who left Canada and went to Afghanistan after the 9/11 attacks with the intention of attacking and killing American and Canadian forces. He lived in bin Laden』s compound, trained with al Qaeda, and killed an American solider with a hand grenade, before he was captured and taken to Guantanamo Bay.

In June 2002, detainee was encouraged by his father, a senior Al-Qaida leader in Canada and close associate of Usama Bin Laden n, to travel to Khowst, AF, to translate for Al-Qaida personnel and to participate in Jihad against the United States. Detainee received training and instruction on how to build and plant Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs) and how to plant land mines (it is not known where or when the detainee learned these skills). Detainee has also admitted to taking part in several mining and combat operations. In July 2002, detainee was present during a raid on a suspected Al-Qaida compound by US Special Forces, during which a gun battle ensued. During the raid, detainee threw a hand grenade and killed a US Special Forces soldier. . .

Detainee』s father is a senior Al-Qaida financier and reportedly the fourth in command underneath Usama Bin Laden in the Al-Qaida organization… Detainee excelled at his training in Afghanistan, which included small arms, explosives training, IEDs, mines, mine laying, and configuring IEDs for remote detonation using hand held devices. Detainee admits to having participated in several mining operations and harassing attacks against US Forces, in addition to throwing the grenade that killed a US solider.

Detainee has never expressed any genuine remorse for the killing of that soldier. He has direct family affiliations with senior Al-Qaida members, has received advanced specialized training in explosives, and has directly participated in hostile attacks against US Forces. Detainee claims that his entire family lived at one of Usama Bin Laden』s compounds in Jalalabad, AF. Detainee continues to provide valuable information on his father』s associates, and on non-governmental organizations that the worked with in supporting Al-Qaida, as well as other major facilitators of interest to the US. Detainee has also provided valuable information on the Derunta, Al-Farouq and Khalden training camps, indicating that the detainee has been to and likely trained at these locations; and he continues to provide valuable information on key Al-Qaida and Taliban members. . . . [H]e remains committed to extremist Islamic values.

Khadr expressed no remorse for killing an American and remains committed to jihad. The idea that Canada would apologize to a man like this, much less pay him a reported $8.1 million in 「damages」 is simply ludicrous.

The soldier Khadr killed is Sgt. Christopher Speer — a US special operations medic who risked his life not only to protect American and Canadian troops, but innocent Afghans as well. The National Post of Canada reports:

During an attack on an al-Qaida hideout in the midst of the war in Afghanistan, Sgt. Christopher Speer walked out into a minefield.

Two Afghan children were lying wounded among the landmines. Speer applied a tourniquet to one, and flagged down a military truck to take the children to a field hospital.

The Journal of Special Operations Medicine, in a tribute to Speer, wrote that selfless acts like these were celebrated at his funeral, held just weeks later.

There is only one upside of this settlement: Now Sgt. Speer』s widow can now go after the money. The National Post reports:

A reported multi-million-dollar payout from the Canadian government to former Guantanamo Bay prisoner Omar Khadr could create an opportunity for the widow of a man Khadr was convicted of killing in a firefight to seek compensation.

Tabitha Speer could 「absolutely」 go after Khadr』s assets once he has some, said Howard Anglin, a former deputy chief of staff and legal advisor to Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper. . . .

Speer』s wife and [another soldier Layne] Morris who was blinded in one eye in the same attack] sued Khadr for damages and won a default $134 million in 2015 in a Utah court. The settlement was never enforced, which would have required legal action in Canadian court…. 「When you get a judgment in another country, in a legal system that Canada generally recognizes, like the US, you need to get a court in Canada to recognize that judgment. So you』d bring an action in Canada to get the Utah judgment recognized,」 Anglin said.

「I suspect that they didn』t do that previously because [Khadr] had no assets. So you』d be spending money on legal fees, coming to court with no prospect of recovering anything. So now that there are assets, in theory at least, they should be able to get the judgment enforced. . . . I』d be surprised if they didn』t.」

Here』s hoping that every single penny Khadr has now goes to the Speer family and to Speer』s comrade, Layne Morris. As Morris told CTV Canadian television, 「He shouldn』t be getting a dime. He should feel grateful that he』s walking the streets in the first place. . . . His family owes humanity an apology, to be very blunt. Not the other way around. Canada owes this man nothing.」

Amen.

程序正義有時候看起來很蠢，但是起到了一個標杆和邊界紅線的作用，讓平時大多數情況下人們的權益，法律邊界等等更加清晰。

誒。。。

支持加拿大自由黨資助伊斯蘭，但前提是錢要讓華人社區來交。應該對華人社區的愛國大媽征90%所得稅，每年征10%房產稅。血稅也可以開徵，每年徵發1000名愛國小粉紅調解不同教派穆斯林的矛盾，被打死的話火化費由他們父母出。

呵呵，對於某些故意誤導帶節奏的問題，我也是無fuck可說。

對於這個問題，還請你們調查清楚好吧？沒有調查就沒有發言權。

這事的起因是因為他爸在80年代被加拿大政府派到阿富汗去做軍事顧問和蘇聯人打仗，而不幸的是，他爸被蘇聯紅軍打死了。這小子只能跟著塔利班混。而更不幸的是這小子在一次美軍突襲的時候被逮了，關塔那摩監獄了。

然後提問是，加拿大政府給一個恐怖分子賠償。呵呵。是加拿大政府讓他成的恐怖分子，賠償有錯？

至於白左？這他么加共這種從1921年過來的，經過一次分裂，仍堅持馬克思列寧主義（暴力革命）的老牌共產黨都看不下去好吧？

這不賠償還有天理了？

更可怕的是，Google人名跳出來的頭幾條新聞居然不是中立就是說賠的對：

被殺死和受傷的美國大兵家屬趕緊去起訴他和加拿大政府啊……

讓他們多吐幾個1050萬出來

歡迎來到加拿大，這裡擁有蜜汁極端的友善和關愛。

為什麼不就他殺死美軍和炸傷美軍進行起訴

這樣的政府遲早被消滅，白左加穆斯林就是這個世界的兩大癌症，穆斯林恐襲後，往往洗地的不是所謂的溫和穆斯林，而是這些白左。加拿大需要布雷維克，好好清楚下。