ISIS販賣人體器官是假新聞嗎？

01-06

前一陣子看到丁香園的文章說，「偷腎」這個事情是假的，不能夠隨便找個人把腎割下來然後移植。但是呢，昨天有在央視新聞上看到這個消息，還附帶一些圖片說ISIS販賣人體器官來斂財，有心臟、肝臟、腎臟什麼的，這就讓我有疑問了，央視播的這條消息是真的嗎？如果是假的，那麼原因是什麼呢？

圖片我不知道是不是真的。

不過就整件事來說，我不相信CNN和UN會造假。

退一萬步說，人家可是黎凡特伊斯蘭國，醫生和醫院肯定是不缺的。

United Nations investigates claim of ISIS organ theft
New York (CNN) The United Nations is looking into claims that ISIS -- already considered the wealthiest terrorist group on record -- may be harvesting organs from slain civilians and gaining financial benefits by trafficking the body parts, officials said Wednesday.
But Britain"s ambassador to the U.N., Mark Lyall Grant, said the issue has not been officially discussed. Grant said there was no proof or evidence of the claim made by Iraq"s ambassador to the United Nations.
The Iraqi ambassador, Mohamed Alhakim, on Tuesday urged the Security Council to investigate the deaths of 12 doctors in Mosul, Iraq. He said they were killed after refusing to remove organs from bodies.
"Some of the bodies we found are mutilated ... that means some parts are missing," he told reporters, adding that there were openings in the back of the bodies where the kidneys would be located.
"This is clearly something bigger than we think," Alhakim said.

The plunder of bodies for usable organs and tissues is widespread, according to Nancy Scheper-Hughes, director of Organs Watch, a University of California, Berkeley-based documentation and research project.
"Organ theft during wars, civil wars, dirty wars, wars involving undisciplined armies is not uncommon," Scheper-Hughes, chair of Berkeley"s doctoral program in medical anthropology, said in an email.
The U.N."s Iraqi mission on Wednesday said Alhakim was not granting interviews.
"At this point we"re not in a position to corroborate what he says, but obviously any source of illegal financing of groups such as ISIS or other extremist groups is extremely worrisome," U.N. spokesman Stephane Dujarric told CNN.
Nickolay Mladenov, the U.N. special envoy handling Iraq, said the organ theft claim would be investigated.
"We have seen these reports as well," he said. "However, I do not want to hasten to confirm anything before we study them in greater detail."
Mladenov said reports that the group "is using a human trafficking as part of its sources of income" have circulated for months.
"I cannot speak to the extent of that issue until we finalize our analysis of the problem but if one looks at the broader picture, it is very clear that the brutality and the tactics that (ISIS) is using expand by the day."
The U.S. State Department said it was aware of the "deeply disturbing comments" about the alleged organ trafficking but wasn"t able to confirm them.
"We also have no reason to doubt them given other similar atrocities that have been documented and other heinous crimes for which ISIL has proudly taken credit," the State Department said, using another acronym for the militant group.

Alhakim said there is a market in Europe for the stolen organs. The terror group has taken over airports where the body parts could be flown out in deals arranged between middlemen and buyers, he said.
The mutilated bodies have been found in shallow graves over the last several weeks, he said.
Speaking to the Security Council at a regular meeting on Iraq on Tuesday, Alhakim cited what he said were crimes of genocide by ISIS -- "without even mentioning the traffic of human organs and the theft and trafficking of archaeological items and oil."
"These terrorist groups have desecrated all human values," he said. "They have committed the most heinous criminal terrorist acts against the Iraqi people -- whether Shia, Sunni, Christian, Turkmen."
Last month, Turkey"s semiofficial Anadolu news agency and other outlets reported that ISIS had announced the opening of a medical school in its main stronghold in northern Syria.
"Dead bodies, once they are disarticulated, pulverized, processed, freeze-dried, etc., are so far removed from the "human" person that they are simply commodities," Scheper-Hughes said. "The demand for fresh organs and tissues ... is insatiable."
Scheper-Hughes said fresh kidneys from "the brain dead or from those executed with the assistance of trained organ harvesters are the blood diamonds of illicit and criminal trafficking."
How ISIS is run
ISIS has been defined as the wealthiest terrorist group on record, using a combination of black-market oil sales, extortion and sophisticated social media to raise money to fund its expansion into Iraq and Syria, according to the U.S. Treasury.
The terrorist group pulls in about $1 million a day, according to the Treasury.

Extortion, such as demanding money from truck drivers and threatening to blow up businesses, is another revenue stream for the group, in addition to robbing banks and gold shops.
The income helps finance a growing stream of suicide attacks and assassinations, officials said. It also aids the recruitment of Sunni tribal fighters and finances spectacular prison raids that liberate hundreds of fighters, as well as attacks on police patrols.
ISIS controls vast areas of northern and western Iraq, as well as much of northeastern Syria -- and exercises draconian authority in areas as far apart as Anbar in western Iraq and Aleppo province in northern Syria. The group also continues to pick up endorsements and pledges of allegiance from other jihadist groups, most notably in Libya and Egypt.

器官販賣是有組織的犯罪，賓館偷腎不見得是真的，但是對一個龐大的恐怖組織來說，這真不是事。

更何況，人家可基本是殺了人再賣。

順便，同阿拉伯國家一樣，中國也是器官出口大國。

1.首先關於ISIS販賣器官這一新聞最早是DailyMail報道的。

鏈接：UN urged to investigate ISIS" trade in human organs

當然目前聯合國只是要開展調查，確定ISIS是否販賣器官。

2.樓上答主說「就ISIS那技術」個人覺得這種說法太武斷了。ISIS不是山溝里的游擊隊，而是控制了相當一大片領土的「割據政權」，在其佔領區內包括伊拉克第二大城市摩蘇爾。在佔領區內的醫院，學校及其他公共設施是正常運行的。也就是說如果IS想進行器官販賣，是具備專業人士及專業設備的，但到底是否存在器官販賣要看聯合國是否展開調查及相應的調查結論了。

別被微博微信什麼遼寧公交在線過度雞湯，還覺得烤腰子梗挺搞笑，於是看到賣人體器官就搬出來「豬腰子」這套理論。

ISIS肯定有能力維持負責配型的醫院。

國內這種事情也別放鬆警惕，說不定人家真有配型技術呢？無風不起浪。

回到問題，我不知道新聞是否屬實，但可以確定肯定ISIS有這個能力，並且ISIS是恐怖組織，什麼事兒干不出來呢。

人家好歹是個組織，不缺醫生的